The South Africa head coach says he expects Sam Prendergast to escape a ban after a hip-drop citing, and says he raised his concerns about the standard of refereeing as “not an accusation”.
South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus has questioned the consistency of officiating in international rugby, asking whether a failure to act on illegal tackles amounted to “match-fixing”. At a media conference on Monday, he predicted that Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast would avoid suspension after being cited for a hip-drop tackle against Fiji. Mr Erasmus said the 23-year-old would be free to face the Springboks in Dublin on Saturday because of a “technicality”. Later on Monday, World Rugby said it would review the coach’s remarks.
The Prendergast citing
Prendergast is the first player to be cited under World Rugby’s new rules on hip-drop tackles. The incident came in the 23rd minute of Ireland’s 43-15 win over Fiji, according to RTÉ Sport. It was not penalised during the match by referee Angus Gardner or television match official Mike Adamson. Fiji captain Peceli Yato carried on after the tackle but was later forced off. Reuters and RTÉ reported that he had a suspected ankle injury.
Mr Erasmus, 54, called the tackle “terrible” and said that when he saw it he thought it was an “immediate red card”. He said he expected Prendergast to play nonetheless. “I must say the right words now. We are in the northern hemisphere. I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play,” he said. Asked what he meant, he said he was “not a legal guy” but that “it never seems to go our way”. He added: “I’m not saying anybody’s doing anything wrong. I’m just not expecting him to get [suspended] – I think he’ll play on Saturday.”
RTÉ understands that under the Nations Championship process a cited player can accept the charge and receive a set sanction. If Ireland contest it, the case goes before an independent disciplinary panel. The42 reported that a citing commissioner must consider the incident worthy of a red card before a player can be cited. A citing does not itself establish wrongdoing or guarantee a ban.
The Irish Examiner reports that Connacht’s Ciarán Frawley is the leading candidate to replace Prendergast if he is suspended. Ulster’s uncapped Jamie Benson could be promoted to the matchday bench. Munster’s Jack Crowley is unavailable through injury.
Reuters reported that Australia’s Angus Bell was shown a yellow card for a hip-drop tackle on England’s Immanuel Feyi-Waboso earlier this month but was not cited. The agency’s report shows that outcomes under the new law have already varied. It does not establish that the two tackles were equivalent.
Erasmus raises the Furlong and Wessels cases
Mr Erasmus also pointed to Ireland prop Tadhg Furlong, who avoided punishment for an alleged groin grab in Leinster’s United Rugby Championship win over Munster in October. He compared the case with that of South Africa prop Jan-Hendrik Wessels, who was given a nine-match ban last year for a similar offence and missed the Springboks’ November matches.
“Tadhg got off free for the same thing Jan-Hendrik did,” Mr Erasmus said. “I don’t want to go into details because I’m not a legal person, but from a South African point of view, that hurt.” He said that in two identical situations “one guy’s word was taken, and another guy’s word was not taken”. “One guy got nine weeks. He didn’t play for the Springboks, and the other guy played the next weekend. That’s all I’m saying.”
Former Ireland international Donal Lenihan questioned the comparison on RTÉ. He said there was no definitive proof in the Furlong incident, which explained why no suspension followed. He suggested Mr Erasmus was deliberately creating pressure before the match. “He knows exactly what he is doing,” Mr Lenihan said, drawing parallels with the controversy Mr Erasmus generated during the 2021 British and Irish Lions tour.
Claims about the France defeat
South Africa go into the Dublin match after a 21-19 defeat by France in Paris on Saturday. Mr Erasmus said 17 hip-drop or knee-drop tackles by French players went unpenalised by referee Andrea Piardi and TMO Matteo Liperini. He said he believed 11 deserved penalties and three should have been yellow cards. He said he would get into trouble if he showed video evidence.
He said World Rugby held a meeting on the new laws on hip-drop and knee-drop tackles ahead of the November internationals, and that the Ireland and France coaches did not attend. He said his remarks were “not an accusation” against the officials, but questioned World Rugby’s decision to limit TMO interventions. “If he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem. If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing?” he said.
“Is that not interfering with the outcome of a game if you see this injury that happened there, a knee-drop tackle happened there, and it’s been decided that knee-drop tackles are out?” he added. He said his players raised the number of such tackles with Mr Piardi and the officials. “If the TMO didn’t see it, maybe then technology must be better. If he saw it and he ignored it, what does that boil down to? Manipulation of the game or the result or injured players getting injured. So all I’m asking, don’t take TMOs out and discourage them to get involved. Then the wrong team will win and players will get injured.”
The42 reported further complaints from Mr Erasmus. He said France scrum-half Maxime Lucu spent only seven minutes in the sin bin instead of ten. He also said South Africa could submit only five clips to World Rugby for review. The Irish Times reported that he also criticised the disallowing of a South African try before half-time. Mr Erasmus said he had believed his side were trailing 21-14 before learning in the dressing room that the score had been overturned. These are Mr Erasmus’s claims, and World Rugby has not confirmed them.
World Rugby to review the comments
World Rugby told Sky Sports News late on Monday that it would examine Mr Erasmus’s comments under its match-official abuse framework. Sky Sports reported the statement at 22:37 GMT. The review concerns his remarks about officials and not the lawfulness of Prendergast’s tackle. No formal charge, sanction or hearing has been announced.
The framework, the Match Official Abuse Sanction Process, was introduced on 16 July 2026 and applies to international rugby, including the Nations Championship. According to World Rugby, an independent panel can consider whether statements allege bias, improper motives, external interference or deliberate interference with a result. Outcomes range from no further action to a guidance letter, a formal warning or a suspension. The panel considers the language used, the speaker’s position, the reach of the remarks and whether they contributed to abuse of officials.
Italy coach Gonzalo Quesada was initially given an automatic two-match ban under the framework in July, after he criticised officiating in Italy’s Nations Championship defeat by New Zealand. An independent committee reduced the suspension to one match, with a public apology and formal warning, after considering his apology to the referee and acceptance of wrongdoing.
Mr Erasmus has previously been sanctioned by World Rugby. In 2021, while South Africa’s director of rugby, he was banned for two months over an hour-long video criticising the refereeing of the Springboks’ first-Test defeat by the British and Irish Lions. World Rugby found it contained “multiple abusive and insulting comments and attacks on the officials”. The following year he received a two-match ban for tweets criticising officials after a defeat by France.
Saturday’s match
The match takes place at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin on Saturday 21 November, with kick-off at 4.40pm. England’s Christophe Ridley will referee. Angus Gardner, who refereed the Fiji game, and Anthony Woodthorpe of England are the assistant referees. Ian Tempest is TMO, and Tual Trainini of France is the Foul Play Review Officer, according to Planet Rugby.
South Africa have made five changes. Eben Etzebeth returns in the second row alongside Ruan Nortjé, with Lood de Jager dropping to the bench. Mr Etzebeth is due to win his 148th cap, South African Rugby confirmed on Monday. Cameron Hanekom replaces Jasper Wiese at number eight. RTÉ reports that Mr Wiese faces disciplinary proceedings after his red card against France. Ox Nché, Malcolm Marx and Wilco Louw are named in the front row, and the entire starting backline is retained, with Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu at fly-half.
South Africa are on 22 points, one behind New Zealand in the Southern Hemisphere Nations Championship standings. According to Reuters, a losing bonus point in Dublin could still be enough to reach the final if England beat New Zealand and deny the All Blacks any bonus points. In his team announcement, Mr Erasmus said South Africa must be more accurate in converting scoring chances across the full 80 minutes.
