Members who won back the House are divided over whether to try. Some, including Jamie Raskin, warn that a hasty effort would hand a weakened president a rallying cry, while Trump says he would welcome the fight.
House Democrats will take back the majority in January and will have the power to impeach President Donald Trump for a third time. By their own accounts, they have not agreed on whether to try. Politico interviewed 14 Democrats across the party’s ideological range, and found a growing number open to using their new majority against Mr Trump. Many also warn that a rushed effort would backfire. Hakeem Jeffries is expected to become speaker with the largest majority for any party in decades, after a wave that cost Republicans close to 50 seats.
Why some Democrats are cautious
Democrats have accused Mr Trump of a sweeping range of misconduct in his second term: self-enrichment, accepting foreign gifts, pay-for-play pardons, abusing his power to target enemies and launching what they call an illegal war in Iran. There is no consensus on which issue would form articles of impeachment, or which investigation should come first.
Some of the caution comes from the members who ran the last two impeachments. Jamie Raskin of Maryland, who is poised to chair the Judiciary Committee and who managed the 2021 trial over the 6 January attack on the Capitol, said a third attempt could play into the hands of a president badly weakened by the midterm rout.
“I think Donald Trump would love us to organize a campaign of impeachment against him right now because he thinks that’s his last hope for rallying the dwindling MAGA base at this point,” Mr Raskin told Politico.
Mr Trump has said much the same. He has long claimed his first two impeachments helped him politically, and told reporters a day after the midterm defeat that he would welcome a third. “I think it would destroy the Democrat Party if they did that, because it would be impeachment for no reason,” he said. “For what? For having a successful country?”
The numbers in the Senate
Impeachment in the House needs only a simple majority, so Democrats could approve articles without Republican support if their own members agreed. Removing a president takes a two-thirds Senate vote, which is 67 if all 100 senators take part. Democrats also won the Senate in the 3 November election, according to projections. Ballotpedia recorded 53 Democratic senators and two independents who caucus with them, with one race still uncalled in its 12 November update. Even a 55-strong bloc would need at least 12 Republican votes to convict. Fox News’s election tracker had called 256 House seats for Democrats as of 16 November.
Previous attempts
Efforts to impeach Mr Trump have already reached the House floor three times since January 2025. All three were tabled, meaning the House set them aside and did not adopt articles of impeachment.
| Date | Resolution | Vote to table |
|---|---|---|
| 24 June 2025 | Al Green resolution | 344-79 |
| 11 December 2025 | Second Al Green resolution | 237-140 |
| 15 September 2026 | Third Al Green resolution | 232-147, with 47 voting present |
The number voting to table fell between June 2025 and September 2026, while more members voted against tabling. That is a shift in recorded votes. It does not show a majority now supports a particular new resolution. John Larson and Steve Cohen also filed articles in April and September 2026, neither of which produced a successful House vote.
A Politico poll taken before the midterms, reported by Forbes on 16 November, found 54% of respondents believed Mr Trump had committed impeachable offences. Some 24% said impeachment would make him more popular, against 18% who thought it would make him less popular. Those are respondents’ opinions and not evidence of what would happen.
Investigations first
Democratic leaders are preparing investigations rather than an immediate impeachment vote. Mr Jeffries said on 4 November that no House Democrat had approached him about impeachment since the election, and later said Democrats would follow the evidence and had not predetermined an outcome, CBS News reported. Axios reported on 6 November that Senate Democrats were already coordinating across committees to avoid duplicate hearings. Chris Van Hollen described efforts to divide responsibilities. The discussions involve presenting documents, witness testimony and findings through a sustained series of hearings, though no single consolidated committee has been established. Reuters reported that Democrats were also considering investigating private companies and financial institutions connected to the administration, which could let committees examine business transactions and government contracts without relying only on White House officials.
Robert Garcia, who is expected to chair the House Oversight Committee, has named four priority areas, Punchbowl News and NPR reported. These are proposed inquiries, not findings of wrongdoing:
- Trump family business interests: cryptocurrency ventures, overseas investments, property projects and alleged conflicts of interest.
- Immigration enforcement: Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement contracts, detention operations and the treatment of migrants.
- Jeffrey Epstein records: whether government documents were improperly withheld or redacted.
- Corporate influence: federal contracts, political donations and possible preferential treatment.
Reuters identified further possible inquiries involving the planned White House ballroom and federal contractors, noting that companies mentioned are not necessarily accused of wrongdoing. Mr Trump and his allies reject allegations of corruption, and the administration has described many of the planned investigations as politically motivated, the Financial Times reported.
Axios reported that the Senate Armed Services Committee is preparing hearings on the US war with Iran when the new Congress convenes, with Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth expected to be called. An early vote on a war-powers resolution is also being discussed. No hearing date or witness list has been confirmed.
White House pushes back
On 16 November, White House Counsel Will Scharf told executive agencies to obtain White House approval before allowing employees to testify before congressional committees, Axios reported. The memo requires clearance from the Counsel’s Office and the Office of Legislative Affairs. It could complicate efforts by incoming chairs to question federal officials. The White House has said it intends to examine whether congressional inquiries have a legitimate legislative purpose. Democrats say their planned investigations fall within Congress’s oversight authority.
On 10 November, Mr Scharf wrote to Mr Garcia warning that some threatened investigative tactics could amount to criminal misconduct, the Associated Press reported. Mr Garcia rejected the warning as an attempt to intimidate lawmakers, saying committees have legal authority to investigate and issue subpoenas, Roll Call reported. The AP also reported that Senator Richard Blumenthal, expected to lead a Senate investigative panel, received a letter from a federal prosecutor demanding the preservation of relevant records. Republican oversight chairman James Comer acknowledged Congress’s independent investigative responsibilities, and the AP said the Justice Department has given differing assessments of congressional oversight powers.
A party with other priorities
Reuters reported on 14 November that Democrats disagreed at a post-election gathering in Denver. Progressives argued for policies including universal healthcare and a wealth tax, while moderates urged the party to show quick results on household costs. Ro Khanna advocated a $25 federal minimum wage and large cuts to Pentagon spending. Congressional time is limited, and a lengthy impeachment would compete with hearings, budget talks and oversight. Several senior Democrats have raised that trade-off, Reuters reported. The new Congress is due to convene on 3 January 2027.
