Footage shown to jurors features the accused laughing as detectives asked about his phone. Prosecutors say he exploited a vulnerable woman he met online, and Hall denies the allegations.
A jury in Ocala, Florida, has been shown police interview footage of Dwain Hall, 54, laughing as detectives questioned him about material on his phone, at his trial over the death of British music teacher Sonia Exelby. Prosecutors allege Hall groomed Ms Exelby, 32, from Southsea, Portsmouth, over two years before stabbing her to death after she travelled to the US. Hall has pleaded not guilty, and his lawyer has told jurors they will conclude he did not murder her.
What the jury saw
In the interview, which lasted 110 minutes, detectives asked Hall whether pornography on his phone was material he had made or simply watched. He replied: “It aint nothing you wanna see”, then laughed. Asked whether he was into “weird stuff”, he said: “well what do you think?”
Hall declined to give detectives access to anything on the phone beyond calls and texts, including his search history and location data. He also described to investigators the sexual encounters he had with Ms Exelby, including what he called “light choking”.
The court has previously heard that Hall gave detectives what was described as a “wild, nonsensical story” during four hours of questioning, before acknowledging he had been in contact with Ms Exelby for years.
The prosecution case
Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told jurors that Hall met Ms Exelby online about two years before her death. She said he “manipulated her for years”, targeted her because of her mental illness and exploited her “for his own sadistic pleasure”.
Ms Berndt described Ms Exelby as a “beautiful, kind woman” who “sadly, suffered from mental illness for most of her life”. The court heard that Ms Exelby had struggled with suicidal thoughts and had been searching online for someone willing to end her life. Ms Berndt said “many men” were competing for that role, but that “one man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner”. She told jurors that person was Hall. Prosecutors also say his online profile advertised a desire for “complete control” over women.
Prosecutors allege Hall demanded £3,000 to carry out the killing after an earlier plan for the pair to meet in March 2025 fell through. They claim Ms Exelby changed her mind after arriving in the US.
The court heard that during the flight she sent herself an email in which she wrote: “I wish I was home, I can’t get off the plane, I want to beg for help so badly.”
Evidence alleged by prosecutors
Prosecutors allege Hall subjected Ms Exelby to violent sexual encounters before stabbing her four times and burying her in woodland. Her remains were found on 17 October, five days after Hall’s phone was allegedly traced to the same location, where it stayed for an hour and 20 minutes.
They say investigators recovered a bloodstained shovel from Hall’s home and a knife from a package he had sent to a friend in Ohio. They also say a forensic examination of the phone found nude images of Ms Exelby alongside other disturbing material, and that Hall had tried to remove every trace of her from the device.
Her sister’s evidence
Ms Exelby’s sister, Gemma Isaj, broke down as she gave evidence. She told jurors the pair had a difficult childhood and were separated by adoption, then reunited when Ms Exelby turned 18. They stayed very close, she said.
Ms Isaj said her sister had confided that she was frightened. “She told me that she had got into something and she was really terrified and that people had been making some horrible threats to her and against her family, they knew where she was and could locate her,” she said. She added that Ms Exelby had turned to online forums for support and that some people there were preying on her and on friends she had made online.
Ms Isaj had arranged to see her sister on 11 October, without knowing she had gone to the US. When Ms Exelby did not arrive, Ms Isaj received a message saying her sister’s phone was broken and that she could be contacted only through Messenger. She later learned Ms Exelby was missing after speaking to her sister’s partner, and she alerted police. She was again overcome when jurors were shown CCTV footage of her sister in Florida.
The defence
Hall’s lawyer told jurors earlier in the trial: “We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder.” The trial continues.
If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this article, you can call the Samaritans for free on 116 123.
