Charles Stapleton, jailed for at least 31 years for the rape and murder of 80-year-old Teresa Wishart, says HMP Frankland should have done more to protect him. The Ministry of Justice denies negligence.
Charles Stapleton, who is serving life with a minimum of 31 years for the rape and murder of an 80-year-old widow, is seeking £100,000 in compensation after he was doused with a boiling mixture by a fellow prisoner at HMP Frankland in Durham. Stapleton, 60, says the prison service should have done more to protect him from the attack in February 2024, which left him with burns and scarring. The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) denies negligence and calls the assault “unforeseeable and unpredictable”. The claim is due to go to a two-day trial next summer.
The claim
Stapleton was attacked with a mixture of boiling water and butter. He says he was left with scarring to his face, neck, shoulder, chest and hand, and complains of “social embarrassment”. His claim alleges that a prison officer had earlier found the attacker, named as fellow prisoner Carl Losh, heating butter and water in a pan and let him carry on. Stapleton argues that a guard should have realised an attack was being planned.
A judge has approved legal costs of £96,419 for Stapleton’s own lawyers and £84,120 for the MoJ. The costs will fall on the taxpayer. The MoJ’s lawyers deny negligence and maintain that the attack could not have been foreseen or predicted.
The 2017 killing
Stapleton killed Teresa Wishart at her home on Changford Road in Kirkby, Merseyside, in October 2017. He had befriended the widow only months earlier and done odd jobs for her. Liverpool Crown Court heard that a neighbour saw him climb into Mrs Wishart’s garden between 10.30pm and 11pm on 18 October. Mrs Wishart’s youngest daughter found her body on the living room floor the next morning, when she called round to take her shopping.
The same morning, Stapleton sold Mrs Wishart’s wedding ring, a second ring, a watch and a pair of earrings at a pawnbroker’s in Kirkby town centre for £110. The court also heard that, in the early hours of 18 October, he had posted on Facebook that he “could quite easily kill again and do another 30yrs”.
Following house-to-house inquiries, he was arrested on suspicion of burglary and later for murder and rape. When cautioned, he said: “Murder and rape, that’s not what I’m about, check my record.” He pleaded guilty to murder and burglary, and admitted rape on the first day of his scheduled trial.
Sentencing
Stapleton was jailed in 2018. The court heard he was a habitual user of cocaine, heroin, crack cocaine, cannabis and Spice, and had 108 previous convictions, including numerous burglaries, dishonesty offences and drug possession. His barrister, Simon Christie, said Stapleton could not recall what led him to burgle the home and commit “these dreadful acts which appal and disgusts him”. He said his client had taken a “potentially toxic” combination of drugs.
Judge Clement Goldstone QC, the Honorary Recorder of Liverpool, rejected any suggestion that a “drug-crazed state” had blocked out Stapleton’s memory of the “sheer wickedness and inhumanity” of his actions. He said Stapleton and his victim came from “opposite ends of the spectrum of character, responsibility and behaviour in every-day life”. The judge added that he was satisfied Mrs Wishart was seen as “an easy target” and that it was “beyond belief of any right-thinking human being” that he went on to rape her.
Mrs Wishart
Mrs Wishart, a mother of four and grandmother of 11, had lived on Changford Road since 1967. Her husband Christopher died in 1996. She attended St Mary’s RC Church in Northwood, where she also volunteered as a cleaner. One neighbour described her as “very lovely, like the mother of the street”.
In a victim personal statement, her youngest daughter said she had been “so proud” of her home, where she felt “safe and content”. She had hoped to leave it to her children as her legacy, and to be cremated and sent off from her own home. Her eldest daughter said a “monster” had denied her mother a dignified death, the funeral arrangements she had made and the chance for her family to kiss her goodbye.
