Karen Selby alleges that her son’s body was unpreserved when she viewed it, weeks before his funeral. The Staten Island funeral home’s owner says the work met the firm’s standards.
A mother has sued a Staten Island funeral home, alleging her son’s body was in a decomposing, unpreserved condition when she viewed it before his funeral. Karen Selby is suing the owners of Martin Hughes Funeral Home over the care of her son, Kendre Selby, a 41-year-old Air Force veteran who died on 24 December 2025, according to papers filed in Brooklyn Supreme Court on 9 November. The suit, reported by the New York Post, accuses the business of improperly embalming the body and failing to refrigerate it properly. The home’s owner, Rocco Paccione, denies that his firm did anything improperly.
The allegations
Mr Selby, who was born in Columbus, Mississippi, died unexpectedly in New York City, according to his obituary. He served three years in the Air Force before becoming a finance and technology entrepreneur. A later obituary published on 18 February says he reached the rank of E-4 and graduated from Woodside High School in Newport News, Virginia, in 2002.
Ms Selby told the Post that she hired Metropolitan Funeral Home in Norfolk, Virginia, to make the arrangements, and that it subcontracted Martin Hughes to prepare her son’s body for transfer. Martin Hughes’s website lists a charge of about $700 for embalming and at least $350 for transportation, according to the Post.
The lawsuit says that when Ms Selby viewed her son’s body on 15 January it “was in a decomposing, unpreserved condition”. Her attorney, Phil Rizzuto, said the funeral service had to be postponed until 6 February and was held with a closed casket. “Her son was 41 when he died, he died suddenly on Christmas Eve, that was a shock in itself,” Mr Rizzuto said. “Then they didn’t embalm him correctly and it was even more traumatic.”
She is seeking unspecified damages for emotional distress and trauma. “My son just didn’t deserve this,” Ms Selby said.
The funeral home’s response
Mr Paccione, the owner of Martin Hughes Funeral Home, told the Post: “My heart goes out to this woman. But everything was done to our standards… there should not have been an issue.” The allegations have not been tested in court, and no formal response to the complaint was available.
What affects how long embalming lasts
The American Academy McAllister Institute describes embalming as the chemical preservation, disinfection and restoration of a body after death. It says embalmed bodies can stay without significant decay for anywhere from weeks to several years. Dominick Astorino, a professor at the Worsham College of Mortuary Science in Chicago, said many factors have to be considered. These include the cause of death, the time between death and embalming, the time between embalming and viewing, and any medication or illegal drugs in the system at death. He said embalmers account for these by adjusting the strength and amount of embalming fluid and by using other techniques. Mr Astorino was not commenting on this case.
Dates that do not match
The funeral dates in the public record differ from the account in the lawsuit. An obituary published on 21 January by Metropolitan Funeral Service listed a viewing on 23 January and a celebration of life on 24 January. The lawsuit account says the service was postponed until 6 February. It is not clear which date marked the final funeral.
Regulation and oversight in New York
Martin Hughes Funeral Home appears on the New York State Department of Health’s register of funeral establishments, which lists Mr Paccione as the associated funeral director. The register shows registration status only. It says nothing about the care given in this case.
A State Comptroller’s audit published on 26 November 2025 found weaknesses in oversight of embalming preparation rooms. Auditors examined 32 registered funeral businesses and concluded the Health Department lacked sufficient assurance of compliance at 22 of them, about 69%. Officials told auditors that inspectors had largely stopped routine visits around 2006 because of budget constraints, relying instead on photographs submitted at initial registration. Updated photographs were not routinely required at two-yearly renewals. Twelve of the 32 businesses had no preparation-room photographs on file. The audit made 12 recommendations. It did not name Martin Hughes as having deficiencies and cannot establish negligence in Mr Selby’s case.
In a separate case, State Attorney General Letitia James announced a 20-count indictment on 1 April against the funeral operator Michael Naughton. Prosecutors say he continued to run Camelot Funeral Home in Mount Vernon after losing his funeral director’s licence. An unannounced inspection on 30 January found 13 bodies in various stages of decomposition and 17 boxes of cremated remains. The allegations, which include grand larceny, fraud and unlicensed funeral directing, have not been proven in court. The case has no known connection to Martin Hughes.
The legal background
Under New York rules, embalming is not automatically required. The Attorney General’s office says it depends on the type of service and circumstances, and refrigeration can be an alternative. Funeral homes must give customers written, itemised pricing, including relevant third-party charges, which could make contracts and invoices important evidence. State regulations (section 77.5) require a dedicated preparation room for embalming. Public Health Law section 3456 allows fines, licence suspension or revocation for violations, though a civil lawsuit alone does not establish one.
A 2024 Bronx Supreme Court decision, Bailey v Owens Funeral Home, dealt with allegations of improperly prepared remains. It involved New York’s common-law right of sepulcher, which concerns the rights of certain family members to arrange the respectful disposition of a relative’s remains. The court discussed whether a separate emotional-distress claim duplicated the sepulcher claim. The full complaint in Ms Selby’s case has not been seen, so it is not known what causes of action her lawyers have pleaded.
