The Scottish Government’s Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc) Bill would add two new bands for homes worth more than £1m. Opposition critics say the sum raised would “barely touch the sides”.
The Scottish Government has published a Bill creating two new council tax bands for homes worth more than £1m, estimating that 13,600 properties will pay the higher charges and raise £17.1m in 2028-29. Homes in Band I would pay an extra £720 a year compared with the current top rate, rising to £3,600 more for Band J homes valued above £2m. Assessing which properties qualify is expected to cost £10m, and the Scottish Conservatives say the revenue will “barely touch the sides”.
What the Bill proposes
The SNP government published the Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc) Bill on Wednesday. The new Band I covers homes worth more than £1m, and Band J covers those valued above £2m. The first-year revenue estimate of £17.1m relates to 2028-29. Local assessors would be paid to judge which homes are worth more than £1m, at an estimated cost of £10m.
An initial projection shows that more than half the affected homes are in Edinburgh.
How homes would be valued
Under the Bill, assessors would value a home on its physical state in January 2028 but judge that against market conditions in April 2026. This means extensions and conversions built between now and January 2028 will be taken into account.
There will be no wider revaluation. All the other bands will still be determined by the last revaluation, carried out in 1991.
Reaction
Craig Hoy, the Scottish Conservative finance spokesman, said: “John Swinney has made Scotland the highest-taxed part of the UK, yet his answer to the crisis in local government is to pile more pressure on households rather than get a grip of his own spending.”
He added: “Some homeowners could face staggering council tax bills, yet communities will still be watching libraries close, roads crumble and frontline services struggle. This is not a solution to the problems facing councils, when the money this will raise will barely touch the sides. The SNP has failed Scotland’s councils for almost two decades. It cannot tax its way out of that failure. Swinney needs to rein in his government’s bloated spending and finally give councils a fair funding deal.”
Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth said: “This legislation builds on our progressive approach to taxation, which helps to target investment in economic growth and support cost of living measures not available elsewhere in the UK.”
